False dichotomy

Mr. A thinks X and Y are in conflict and "distant" But Mr. B thinks that X and Y are close, that there is a Z that opposes them.

concrete example - Mandatory regular leave also low discretionary status - A" counterposes "thorough implementation of no-overtime day X" with "forced overtime work condition Y" of a black company. - B counterposes discretionary work Z with no fixed hours, which both X and Y see as "a state of being deprived of discretion over when to work".

• I don't want to live, but I don't want to die either."

  • Mr. A believes it is a dichotomy between "wanting to live" and "wanting to die."
  • Mr. B says, "I don't want to die," "I don't want to live," and "I just want to go away."
    • Dichotomy of "wanting to be active" and "not wanting to be active"
    • I recognize that both "living" and "dying" are active actions.
      • (Off-topic if this perception is correct)

• "Does a dog have Buddha nature?" (classic Zen koan)" is a false dichotomy.

  • Whether dogs have Buddha nature or not is a false dichotomy
  • see the sound of one hand clapping (a classic Zen koan)

• One of the specific patterns of [dialectics

  • dialectic development

Q: What is the relationship with false dichotomy?

• The point about the "false dichotomy" implicitly assumes the existence of a boundary, which begs the question, "Is there really a boundary?" I get the sense that you're asking the question, "Are there really boundaries?
• The "false dichotomy" doesn't negate the original conflict itself.
  • There is an additional axis of conflict. - There is more than one axis.
  • It's like you're telling someone who implicitly sees the original conflict as a "big one" that it's a small conflict and there's a bigger one.
    • Maybe it's subjective whether it's big or not.

relevance - Conflict is a close relationship in There is more than one conflict. - e/a and e/acc are false dichotomies

• A series of pictures of two people saying different things
  • Can we put it in the blind spot card?
    • Blind Card Candidate

This page is auto-translated from /nishio/誤った二項対立 using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I'm very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers. False dichotomy There is no clear boundary, gradation, and yet we assume there is. - The False Dichotomy of Programmer/Non-Programmer

A gradient, but one that doesn't express itself in the picture. - False dichotomy of beneficial/non-beneficial - avoiding one's weak points

- The concept of [undifferentiated

relevance - all-or-none thinking - Are the boundaries clear?

• blind spot card 30

This page is auto-translated from /nishio/誤った二分法 using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I'm very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.