Nada School Saturday Class 2025
2025-05-24
I'll just reprint my part.
- 
- 
- What is /plurality-japanese/plurality?
question
Isn't there a possibility that the AI could skew it when it collects the opinions of many people and puts them together?
- Of course there is that.
- Related question: is there a bias in the LLM?
- Diverse biases by LLMs. - Ask Qarasu-14B a question
- But is there no bias if it is put together by a human being? Of course, humans have biases.
- So this is not an "AI or human" issue.
- Issues that should be resolved by creating mechanisms such as making the process open and verifiable by a third party
- Related question: will AI be a black box?
- Reasoning model works by verbalizing and outputting the thinking process, and is less of a black box than a person who thinks silently.
- Research is also underway to examine the internal firing of the model during task execution. This is like sticking electrodes into the brain if you were to use a human analogy.
- Stabbing electrodes into public officials is ethically difficult, but disclosing the internal state of AI in public service will be possible in the future.
- If you think being a black box is a problem, you'd rather use AI instead of humans.
- Related question: will AI be a black box?
- Reasoning model works by verbalizing and outputting the thinking process, and is less of a black box than a person who thinks silently.
- Of course there is that.
Not all people can think and speak out about politics, what do we do with those who don't?
- Some radical views like unconscious data democracy are not in favor of it.
- The current lack of opportunities for people to have their opinions heard and to feel good about expressing them is the reason why the ability to think and express opinions is not developed.
- Especially minors do not have the right to vote, and when they come of age, they are suddenly told they should vote, which is absurd.
- In Taiwan, systems such as JOIN created opportunities for students to voice their opinions from the student stage. - High School Students' Suggestions Led to Institutional Improvements at JOIN in Taiwan - Similar clusters were seen in [Shin Tokyo 2050 Broad Listening
- Today's major social networking sites are marked by people with radical opinions.
- Most people don't want to argue with radicals.
- The pro-social media mindset is designed to draw attention to "Bridging Opinions" that are favored by those in different opinion clusters. - Bridging Bonus
Influence the international community?
- Of course, the elimination of language barriers is significant
Q: If the generated AI creates a manifesto based on "what opinion will be received by citizens", won't all parties be the same?
- When they gather in large clusters, differences disappear and supporters are more likely to be in flux, which the existing parties do not like.
- When you visualize it, there are clusters that are not represented by a political party even at this point in time.
- Even a small cluster can become a political party with 1%.
- The assumption that all parties should go to large clusters is incorrect because it is a red ocean to go for a majority.
- In the long run, it's unclear whether party politics will continue to feel the same way as it does now in the first place.
- The balance of advantages and disadvantages of the party line is affected by the balance of advantages and disadvantages of the party line.
- It may not be stable if the support base changes from one place to another.
- I'm not sure where you're coming from with the assumption that it won't change, that it will change from one thing to another.
This page is auto-translated from /nishio/灘校土曜講座2025 using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I'm very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.